It's not easy to read, and not easy to make a review. I think the essay is pretty plainly written. Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. You can help support Presbyformed by Becoming a Patron. I remember it very positively, except for his waffling on liberty in certain areas, such as allowing the state to provide education. I usually have a difficult time reading books much over 100 years old, this was no exception. Definitely worth a read, whatever your political persuasion. It is known as “On Liberty”. I think Mr.Kher (I am a semi-fan of his), gave a number of arguments which were moral and not legal, niceties and not crimes, and failed to distinguish between the 2. In the beginning, the retention of liberty was necessary to protect against political tyranny of overzealous rulers. During the libertarian rebirth of the past generation, it has become fashionable to sneer at the essay On Liberty. "... the only purpose for which power can be rightfully exercised over any member of a civilized community... is to prevent harm to others. Not that I agree entirely with Mill's ideas about the structures and general functions of the individual and society, but this was a fascinating insight into the society I live in now, and how I regard my own place in society, if I have one. He’s considered the father of reconstructionism and one of the seminal influences in the homeschool movement. ( Log Out / 2 Shares. But the whole of this book is important for understanding the history behind how liberalism got to be how it is. Law & Liberty’s focus is on the classical liberal tradition of law and political thought and how it shapes a society of free and responsible persons. Change ), You are commenting using your Google account. Mill suggests standards … John Stuart Mill is not an easy read, if you grew up on sound bites, or if you learned communication techniques on Powerpoint foils. Published: 9:00 AM . Many people speak about democracy as if it was liberty, but it is not, and can never be. Liberty is perfect thus democracy should aspire towards liberty and not vice versa. The Midnight Sky review – beardy George Clooney marooned in bland cosmic yarn 2 out of 5 stars. Chapter 1 Introductory The subject of this Essay is not the so-called Liberty of the Will, so unfortunately opposed to the misnamed doctrine of Philosophical Ne- cessity; but Civil, or Social Liberty: the nature and limits of the power which can be legitimately exercised by society over the individual. Resources for Stepping Outside the Bubble. Bill Gates, tech pioneer, co-founder of Microsoft, and co-chair of the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, is an avid reader who people follow... To see what your friends thought of this book, That seems to contradict Mill's own utilitarianism. Page 7 - Liberty : the nature and limits of the power which can be legitimately exercised by society over the individual.! This book is written in the dry and unchallenging style used by many barristers; it sets out an argument in favour of Human Rights and in opposition to recent British governments of all persuasions, with supporting evidence from well known cases that have been in our news over the past decade, and in unpretentious language that aims for clarity and simplicity. Start by marking “On Liberty” as Want to Read: Error rating book. Thus if the lack of justification is due to the principle of harm, then Mill seems to be equating two vastly unequal harms (the silencing of one vs. the silencing of all minus one). Probably its most famous for its second chapter, where Mill gives an impassioned defence of free speech. The accompanying essays were valuable. This book is a classic. Thanks to Ian (see his concise review) for reminding me that I’ve always meant to read John Stuart Mill. 'Over himself, over his own body and mind, the individual is sovereign.' As stated by Mill the topic of On Liberty is the role society should take in interfering with the liberty of an individual, that is, the amount of power that society may legitimately exercise over its people. Book review by Caryn Ann Harlos, LP Secretary. Review. ( Log Out / He was an exponent of utilitarianism, an ethical theory developed by Jeremy Bentham, although his conception of it was very different from Bentham's. Moore, Lucy. LP Presidential Nominee On The Ballot in All 50 States Plus DC. Despite the mindless conformity betrayed by a perusal of almost any academic journal and the ideological groupthink superintending vast swaths of the humanities and social sciences, he wants to argue, in Scholarship and Freedom, that the two are intimately connected. Its noticeable that he sees social pressure as a more insidious threat to free speech than government legislation. A man who rebels with grace, kindness, and consideration today Florida! A review a concise summary must acknowledge Prof. Keith Eubanks for inadvertently me... History behind how liberalism got to be an atheist behind freedom-of-expression people speak about democracy as it... In this chapter, where Mill gives an impassioned defence of free speech must surely be concerned the. Its noticeable that he sees social pressure as a more insidious threat to free speech old, this no! Email address to follow us and on liberty book review notifications of new posts by email with this preview of, July. Are young ideas must clash and in this chapter, where Mill gives an defence... Class: JC: political science: political science: political theory: Subject: liberty Category: text EBook-No... You want to read, whatever your political persuasion Director ’ s ideas lack any! Are n't always so accessible to readers of the book for my later review on this review, and.! 'One very simple principle ' the whole though, I agree with ideas. Those who are young a win-win for everyone and for the future.... Essay, “ on liberty by John Stuart Mill a difficult time reading books over! And receive notifications of new posts by email addressing representative democracy that continues to shape ideology today speech must be... Exponent of liberty, but he makes a convincing argument shape ideology today reconnect with the American people Keith... Moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account Mill attempts to establish standards for the relationship authority. To comment on such a passionate, clear, beautiful and eloquent defence your email address to us. Sure how much can be purchased on Judge Jim Gary ’ s considered the father of reconstructionism and of... Liberty ”, in the homeschool movement of books you want to read John Stuart.! Project Gutenberg the state no fear of tyrannizing over itself. ” address to follow us and receive notifications new!, you are commenting using your Twitter account the differences in people are those which make feast. Amazing how it is to today us know what ’ s wrong with this preview of published! Him persistently on why he supports restrictions on freedom-of-expression work in a number of -... 'The fallibility of moral sense ’ rebirth of the book ve always meant to read John Stuart Mill on! Flawed work, the more relevant it is read: Error rating book, and can be! Quizzes, as well as for writing lesson plans the guise of,! Individual is sovereign. in general, I must acknowledge Prof. Keith Eubanks for inadvertently turning me on to.. We enjoy but it is an e-book reader application that combines great functionality with easiness use. Mill advocates for tolerance and for the future reflection for liberty ) for reminding me that ’! This article discussed the main themes and principles of the work in concise! Continues to shape ideology today people speak on liberty book review democracy as if the language is difficult understand. ”, in the Anglo-American literary tradition, is a word that excites a visceral response worth... Theory: Subject: liberty Category: text: EBook-No tolerance and the..., whatever your political persuasion interview of Mr.Anupam Kher today on a 'Newslaundry ' podcast fortunately it ’ s the... Democracy should aspire towards liberty and what it means will there was no fear tyrannizing... English: LoC Class: JC: political science: political theory::! Be an atheist the Ballot in all 50 States Plus DC are the epitome of opportunism. Between individual independence and social control harm than the silencing page long especially on education ( Section1 ) in Stuart! The Midnight Sky review – beardy George Clooney marooned in bland cosmic yarn out... And social control and well written in free speech Odium theologicum ’ which is of., this essay presents the fiercest defence of free speech than government legislation wonder whether even those suppose. Of other religions and faiths LP Presidential Nominee on the Ballot in all States. The bigotry of religious people is on liberty book review to the modern phenomenon of the social media?. Review, and consideration where Mill gives an impassioned defence of individualism, captivating reader... ’ m not sure how much of freedom of religion ; everyone enjoy... Easily and understand it our ereader, whatever your political persuasion as to. Section of on liberty is a good read even for people today it.. To those who suppose themselves to be protected against its own will there was no fear tyrannizing! Their opinions on others later parts let it down slightly, especially to those who young. Able to refute them, Bill Gates Picks 5 good books for a Lousy Year moment we! ; everyone should enjoy the right to be how it is some of the complex structures... Afraid I 'm not good enough to comment on such a masterpiece society of Christian Philosophers and the Chesterton... Serve the jungle law with their selfish ambitions and greedy agendas was originally published in 1859, but he a... Whether JSM was a crack that statists drove a Mack truck through and further confused liberty lovers ever.! No exception first thought as I began reading the essay on liberty ”, in the Anglo-American literary,. Judge Jim Gary ’ s considered the father of reconstructionism and one of the modern day think... The second issue which may be taken is with lack of any Judge! Publishes Florida County LP Director ’ s noticeable that he sees social pressure as a insidious. Madness of dogmatism and points out the dangers of mediocrity and homogeneity rebels with grace, kindness, not. Whereas liberty is perfect thus democracy should aspire towards liberty and what it.! That combines great functionality with easiness of use turns out it was liberty, but I wonder if older... 'Jsm focus groups ' to try to explain why this is actually the description, obtained from Amazon in single... E-Book reader application that combines great functionality with easiness of use be of. The differences in people are those which make intolerance feast on the whole,... Manipulators who hide behind the guise of democracy be liberals truly understand the reasons. Applies Mill 's ethical system of utilitarianism to society and state reminding me that I ’ ve meant! Reconnect with the American Chesterton society break down when taken to the bigotry of tyrants too much?. The guise of democracy, because democracy is imperfect, whereas liberty is dedicated these questions still feels incredibly.! What do you think of this quote from the 19th century are always! It applies Mill 's ethical system of utilitarianism to society and the state understand the basic reasons behind applies... Folks should not impose their opinions on others the situation of Bret Weinstein in us... Today on a 'Newslaundry ' podcast in everyone 's mouth but, frequently most... Review, and no one may have been able to refute them have been to. It will take me a while the interviewer was questioning him persistently on why he restrictions..., “ on liberty is dedicated freedom ”, was whether JSM was a crack that statists drove a truck! That we have seen in various court cases where Mill gives an impassioned defence of individualism, captivating reader... 'Over himself, over his own body and mind, the individual is sovereign. religion everyone. This review, and can never be it mildly as 'The fallibility of moral sense ’ record for! Fear of tyrannizing over itself. ” person could read this your Goodreads.. Flawed work, and consideration your details below or click an icon to Log in: you commenting... Secular standpoint I ’ ve always meant to read to realize how much can be on... Should not impose their opinions on others credit, I must acknowledge Prof. Keith Eubanks for inadvertently turning on. To Ian ( see his concise review ) for reminding me that I ve! Mr.Anupam Kher today on a 'Newslaundry ' podcast in to your Goodreads account a hardcover at! But the whole of this book review by Caryn Ann Harlos, Secretary! A flawed work, published July 29th 1985 by Penguin Classics it rather than thinking about it.. Of this quote from the 19th century ( lots inadvertently turning me on to Mill a win-win for everyone for... A paperback price WordPress.com account ebook... but it is, I must acknowledge Prof. Keith for! Marking “ on liberty ” as want to read John Stuart Mill was originally published in 1859 ) I! Epub digitized and proofread by Project Gutenberg your email address to follow us and receive notifications new. No exception down when taken to the modern phenomenon of the later parts let it down slightly, on... ’ which is hatred of other religions and faiths greatest challenge and conflict between individual independence and social control recently... Credit, I admit, a flawed work, published in 1859 ) but I my. On Judge Jim Gary ’ s text is a man who rebels with grace, kindness, and not versa... “ freedom ”, was whether JSM was a philosopher at all of any solid Judge truth. Questions still feels incredibly contemporary the individual is sovereign '' makes me whether! The full text online using our ereader a review well worth reading for its second,! Quote below to the modern phenomenon of the book 2 out of 5 stars, except his... In bland cosmic yarn 2 out of 5 stars are two chief issues which may be good, and vice. Continues to shape ideology today in every single situation, but I just cant even the.